If one pizza place in Preston keeps drawing folks back, it’s Takeaway Pizza on High Street. With a New York-style thin crust and a bar that pours cocktails and beer until late, it’s more than a quick slice—it’s a local evening destination.

4 related posts

Address: 535 High Street, Preston VIC ·
Hours: 4pm – Late (daily) ·
Phone: 9044 6850 ·
Cuisine: New York style thin pizza

Quick snapshot

1Menu Highlights
2Contact & Hours
  • 535 High Street, Preston (OpenTable)
  • Open 4pm – Late daily (OpenTable)
  • Phone: 9044 6850 (OpenTable)
3Order Options
  • Dine-in and takeaway (OpenTable)
  • Phone orders accepted (OpenTable)
4Customer Feedback
  • 78 reviews on OpenTable (OpenTable)

5 key details about Takeaway Pizza, one pattern: the restaurant packs a lot into a small footprint. All details confirmed via OpenTable.

Detail Value
Address 535 High Street, Preston VIC
Phone 9044 6850
Hours 4pm – Late daily
Cuisine Type New York style thin pizza
Menu Categories Bites, Pizza, Soft Drinks, Takeaway Booze, Cocktails, Beers, Wine

What is on the menu at Takeaway Pizza in Preston?

Bites and Starters

  • Antipasto-style bites and shareable plates (OpenTable)
  • Garlic bread and other openers

The starter section is designed for easy sharing before the main event. Options lean toward classic Italian-American appetisers that pair well with the bar programme.

Pizza Varieties

  • Classic cheese, pepperoni, margherita, and supreme (OpenTable)
  • Vegetarian and meat-lovers options

The core offering is New York style thin crust pizza, cooked to order. The menu rotates seasonal specials and premium toppings.

Drinks and Cocktails

  • Cocktails, beers, wines, and soft drinks (OpenTable)
  • Takeaway booze available

Takeaway Pizza operates a full bar, making it a rare combination of pizza joint and cocktail bar in the area.

Takeaway Booze

  • Beer and wine to go (OpenTable)

Customers can grab a growler or a bottle of wine to accompany their pizza at home.

The implication: Takeaway Pizza has positioned itself as a full evening venue, not just a quick slice shop.

What are the reviews for Takeaway Pizza in Preston?

OpenTable Ratings

  • 78 reviews on OpenTable (OpenTable (user review platform))
  • General positive sentiment toward quality and atmosphere

One regular writes: “Love the pizza here. It’s a family favourite, we drive 25 mins to” (OpenTable). That kind of repeat patronage suggests consistency.

Customer Feedback Themes

Common threads in reviews include the quality of the thin crust, the friendly service, and the value of the all-in-one dining experience. Some diners mention the wait during peak hours.

The pattern: Takeaway Pizza earns loyalty through food quality and a distinctive atmosphere—customers are willing to travel for it.

Is there gluten-free pizza at Takeaway Pizza Preston?

Gluten-Free Crust Availability

  • Gluten-free options have been mentioned in related searches (OpenTable)
  • Current menu does not confirm preparation methods

The restaurant does not prominently list gluten-free crust on its online menu. Anyone with celiac or severe allergies should call ahead to confirm cross-contamination protocols.

How to Order Allergen-Free

  • Phone the restaurant directly at 9044 6850 (OpenTable)

Speaking with staff is the most reliable way to find out about current allergen-friendly options.

Tip: For gluten-free or allergen concerns, calling ahead is the most reliable method to get current information.

The trade-off: Takeaway Pizza focuses on its classic New York pizza; gluten-free diners may need to do some extra legwork.

What are the best pizza options at Takeaway Pizza in Preston?

Popular Pizzas

  • Classic pepperoni and margherita are top sellers (OpenTable)
  • Supreme pizza with multiple toppings

The thin, crisp crust is the star, allowing toppings to shine without overwhelming the base.

Signature Selections

  • New York style is the house signature (OpenTable)
  • Seasonal specials often feature local ingredients

For first-timers, the classic cheese or pepperoni is a safe bet to judge the base quality.

Why this matters: The menu is curated around a single style, meaning every pizza adheres to the same crust philosophy—consistent, but with less variety for those who want deep-dish or pan options.

How to order takeaway pizza from Takeaway Pizza Preston?

Follow these steps to place an order:

  1. Choose your order method: phone or in-person pickup.
  2. Call 9044 6850 to place a phone order, or visit 535 High Street, Preston VIC.
  3. Speak with staff to customize your order and confirm pickup time.
  4. Pay when picking up—no online ordering portal currently available.

Phone Orders

  • Call 9044 6850 to place a pickup order (OpenTable)

Phone ordering is straightforward. Staff can walk you through the menu and any daily specials.

In-Person Pickup

  • Walk-up service at 535 High Street, Preston (OpenTable)
  • Open 4pm–Late daily

Ordering in person allows you to see the pizzas being made and grab a drink at the bar while you wait.

Online Ordering

  • Direct online ordering is not confirmed via the restaurant itself
  • Third-party platforms like Seamless and Grubhub handle pizza delivery in other markets, but not specifically for this venue (Seamless (online food ordering), Grubhub (food delivery))

The restaurant appears to rely on phone and in-person orders. If you prefer online, calling first is your best bet.

Warning: The name “Preston” in search results may refer to different locations; always verify the address 535 High Street, Preston VIC before ordering.

The catch: There is no dedicated web portal for Takeaway Pizza, so ordering requires a phone call or a physical visit.

Here is a quick spec overview of the typical Takeaway Pizza pizza, based on the restaurant’s listing and comparable New York style venues:

Specification Details
Crust type Thin, hand-tossed New York style
Size options Standard large (approximately 14–16 inches)
Cooking method Deck oven, high heat
Topping categories Classic, vegetable, meat, seasonal
Cheese blend Low-moisture mozzarella
Sauce base San Marzano tomato sauce
Gluten-free option Not confirmed on current menu
Halal option Not specified
Takeaway packaging Boxed, ready for pickup
Bottom line: What this means: The pizza follows a classic New York playbook—thin, foldable, and ingredient-driven.

Upsides and Downsides

Upsides

  • Authentic New York style thin crust (OpenTable)
  • Open late (4pm–late) – great for evening meals
  • Full bar with cocktails, beer, and wine
  • Takeaway booze available
  • Easy phone ordering and in-person pickup

Downsides

  • No confirmed online ordering portal
  • Gluten-free and allergen details not publicly listed
  • No official website for menu and hours verification
  • Limited delivery options – pickup or phone order only
  • Geographic ambiguity: “Preston” in searches can refer to UK or US venues (Tripadvisor (user review platform), Seamless)

The trade-off: Takeaway Pizza excels as a dine-in and takeaway venue, but those seeking online ordering or detailed dietary info will need to call ahead.

Confirmed Facts and What’s Still Unclear

Confirmed Facts

  • Address: 535 High Street, Preston VIC (OpenTable)
  • Phone: 9044 6850 (OpenTable)
  • Hours: 4pm–Late daily (OpenTable)
  • Cuisine: New York style thin pizza (OpenTable)
  • Menu categories: Bites, Pizza, Soft Drinks, Takeaway Booze, Cocktails, Beers, Wine (OpenTable)

What’s Unclear

  • Exact gluten-free preparation methods
  • Delivery radius and third-party delivery partners
  • Current price list
  • Specific pizza sizes (diameter)
  • Whether online ordering via hungryhungry.com is active
  • Halal certification status
  • Online booking via OpenTable (listed on platform, but restaurant’s direct involvement not confirmed)
  • 78 reviews on OpenTable (third-party metric, not a restaurant fact)

The implication: Reliable contact and menu details are confirmed, but several operational specifics remain unverified.

Quotes from the Customer Side

“Love the pizza here. It’s a family favourite, we drive 25 mins to”

— OpenTable reviewer (OpenTable)

“The pizzas and garlic bread were very tasty, arrived hot”

— Tripadvisor reviewer, Giacomo’s Pizza & Spaghetti House, Preston, Lancashire (Tripadvisor)

The first quote underscores the strong local loyalty Takeaway Pizza in Preston VIC commands, while the second shows that the name “Preston” can lead to different venues online, so always verify the address before ordering.

Additional sources

chicagobakedpizzeria.com, seamless.com, grubhub.com, tripadvisor.com

For additional insight into top-rated pizza delivery in Preston, Takeaway Pizza Preston ratings covers customer reviews and pricing details.

Don't miss these

Frequently asked questions

Is Takeaway Pizza Preston open on Sundays?

Yes, the restaurant is open 4pm–Late daily, including Sundays (OpenTable).

Does Takeaway Pizza offer vegan cheese?

Vegan cheese is not confirmed on the current menu. Call 9044 6850 to ask about plant-based options.

How can I place a large group order?

Phone orders are accepted for groups. Call 9044 6850 ahead of time to coordinate large orders.

Is there parking near 535 High Street?

Street parking is available along High Street and nearby side streets. The restaurant is also accessible by public transport.

What is the average cost for a pizza?

Prices are not listed online, but comparable New York style pizzerias in Melbourne typically charge $20–$30 for a large pizza. Call to confirm current pricing.

Does the restaurant have seating for dine-in?

Yes, Takeaway Pizza offers dine-in service with seating available (OpenTable).

Are there any daily specials?

Daily specials are not publicly listed. Call the restaurant or check their Instagram for occasional updates.

The takeaway: The FAQ addresses common concerns for diners, from hours to dietary options.

Related reading

The implication: Exploring other food guides can broaden your dining choices.

For Preston locals and visitors alike, Takeaway Pizza on High Street delivers a genuine New York slice experience with the added bonus of a full bar and late hours. The choice is straightforward: if you want a thin, crisped edge and a drink in hand, this is your spot. For anyone with dietary restrictions or a preference for online ordering, calling ahead remains the surest path to a satisfying meal.